The dismissal of Indian all-rounder Washington Sundar on day one of the New Year's Test at the SCG became a point of discussion. It came during India's first innings when Sundar was adjudged caught behind off Australian captain Pat Cummins.
The on-field umpire, Saikat Sharfuddoula, had initially ruled Sundar not out, but Australia opted for a review.
TV umpire Joel Wilson spent considerable time analyzing the replays to determine whether Sundar had gloved the short-pitched delivery. The snickometer showed a spike as the ball passed near Sundar's glove, but the visuals raised questions. One frame appeared to show no spike when the ball was closest to the glove, while the subsequent frame captured a spike.
Wilson concluded that the evidence was sufficient to overturn the on-field decision. The final verdict flashed on the big screen - 'OUT' - and Sundar was visibly stunned. He attempted to protest but was directed to leave the field, departing for a score of 14.
The decision drew immense anger, and former England skipper Michael Vaughan called it an "awful" decision in disbelief. "No way that's OUT. that's an awful decision.," Vaughan said on X.
Robin Uthappa, former India batter said, "I’m sorry, but that’s a crap decision! Sure, there was a spike, but from the side angle, there was a clear space between the ball and the glove.
There is a lot of ambiguity with these kinds of decisions. The benefit must go to the batter," Uthappa posted on X.
However, former umpire Simon Taufel defended Wilson, explaining that the protocols justified the decision.
"What Joel Wilson is looking for here is that spike up to one frame past the glove, and he has that spike," Taufel said on Channel 7. "There is nothing else out there, and the ball is underneath the glove. The third umpire is well and truly within his rights, according to the protocols, to determine that's conclusive evidence for ball on glove.".
Earlier in the day, another referral regarding Wilson worked in favor of India. Australia players thought Virat Kohli was caught behind at second slip after he edged a Scott Boland delivery.
He was given not out by TV umpire Wilson with the ball apparently scooping the ground, flicking the grass below, while passing to Marnus Labuschagne at gully. At least, on the fielding side, none of the spectators seemed to spot it, for they were furious.
Australian cricket stalwarts, Justin Langer and Ricky Ponting, among others, made their displeasure known.
Read also| Indian Tycoon Sajjan Jindal Attends Nawaz Sharif's Grandson's Wedding in Lahore
Read also| Gambhir Stresses Honesty and Confidentiality in Dressing Room Debates
